A woman studying a nautical chart and paperwork at a desk beside windows overlooking a harbor of moored sailboats
— Insights —

Before You Set a Retirement Date: Five Questions Your Income Plan Should Answer

A retirement date is a decision with a long tail. Before you circle one on the calendar, your plan should be able to answer five questions with your numbers, not rules of thumb.

By Bernie Ross8 min read

What should a retirement income plan answer before you set a retirement date?

It should show which income source pays your essential bills each year and from what start date, which account each year's withdrawal comes from and what tax bracket it lands in, what happens if markets fall in the first five years, how health coverage is paid for until Medicare begins at 65, and how much of your monthly income existing debt still takes. If any of the five has no answer yet, the date is premature.

— Why a date needs a test —

The date is easy to pick. The consequences are not.

Most of the decisions that follow a retirement date are permanent or slow to reverse.

Picking a retirement date feels like a calendar decision. In practice it sets off a chain of others: when each spouse claims Social Security, which pension option is elected, when the paycheck that funds health coverage stops, and which accounts begin to be drawn down. Several of those are permanent. A pension election generally cannot be changed once payments start, and a reduced Social Security benefit stays reduced for life.

Your late 50s and early 60s are the window when most of these choices are still open. No benefit is being drawn yet, no required distribution has started, and your taxable income is still largely in your control. Once the date passes, much of that flexibility goes with it. The five questions below are a way to test a date before you commit to it. Each one can be answered on paper, with your own figures, before anything is filed or signed. For the six common mistakes these questions are designed to catch, see retirement income planning mistakes pre-retirees make.

— Question one —

Which income pays the essential bills, and from when?

Start with the bills, then match each one to a source and a start date.

Split your spending into essential costs (housing, food, insurance, taxes, utilities) and discretionary costs (travel, gifts, projects). Then list every income source with the date it begins: each spouse's Social Security, any pension, part-time work, and planned withdrawals. The goal is a year-by-year view showing which source covers the essential bills in each year, including the years before every benefit has started.

Social Security is usually the largest lifetime source, and the claiming age changes it permanently. For anyone born in 1960 or later, full retirement age is 67. The Social Security Administration's reduction and delayed-credit rules work out as follows.

Social Security benefit as a percentage of the full retirement age amount, by claiming age, for people born in 1960 or later
Claiming ageShare of full benefitWhat it means
6270%Permanent 30% reduction; earliest possible start
67 (full retirement age)100%The unreduced benefit
70124%Delayed credits stop here; about 77% more per month than at 62

A larger check later is not automatically the right answer. Health, other savings and a spouse's record all matter, and a married couple's decision is really two decisions that affect each other. The surviving spouse keeps the larger of the two benefits, so the higher earner's claiming age sets the survivor's income for life. Our Social Security planning work models each spouse at 62, full retirement age and 70 inside the same income schedule.

— Question two —

Which account does each withdrawal come from, and at what tax cost?

The order you draw from accounts can matter as much as how much you draw.

Most pre-retirees hold the bulk of their savings in traditional 401(k)s and IRAs, where every dollar withdrawn is taxable income. Required minimum distributions, the withdrawals the IRS requires from those accounts, begin at 73, or at 75 for anyone born in 1960 or later. Large balances left untouched until then can produce forced withdrawals that push income into a higher bracket for the rest of retirement.

Withdrawals also interact with two other systems. Up to 85% of Social Security benefits can become taxable as other income rises, and Medicare Part B and D premiums carry income-related surcharges (IRMAA) that are set from your tax return two years earlier. A plan should show, year by year, which account funds spending, which bracket that lands in, and whether a Roth conversion in the low-income years between retirement and the first required distribution reduces the lifetime tax bill. The mechanics are covered in the tax torpedo, IRMAA and withdrawal order.

State taxes belong in the same model. New Hampshire repealed its interest and dividends tax for taxable periods beginning January 1, 2025, and Massachusetts does not tax Social Security benefits, but each state treats pensions and retirement account withdrawals differently. Confirm the treatment of your own income sources with your CPA before you rely on it.

— Question three —

What happens if markets fall in the first five years?

The order of returns matters most just after withdrawals begin.

Sequence-of-returns risk is the danger that a market decline arrives early in retirement, while you are selling investments to fund spending. Selling during a decline locks in losses that a portfolio left alone might have recovered. The same average return can produce very different outcomes depending on when the bad years fall.

Holding too little in stocks carries its own cost, because a retirement of 20 to 30 years needs some growth to keep pace with rising prices. Morningstar's research on retirement income for 2026 put the highest starting withdrawal rate with a 90% probability of lasting 30 years at 3.9% of the initial portfolio, adjusted for inflation each year, and found that retirees willing to let spending flex could start higher. That figure is a research benchmark, not a recommendation for your household. Four checks put this question on paper:

  • How many years of planned withdrawals sit in cash and short-term bonds
  • Whether that reserve lets you avoid selling stocks in a down year
  • Whether the stock allocation matches the income the plan needs
  • How spending would change if the portfolio fell 25% in year two
— Question four —

How is health coverage paid for until 65, and after?

Medicare starts at 65 regardless of when the paycheck stops.

Retiring at 61 leaves four years to cover with COBRA, a marketplace plan or a spouse's employer plan. Price that bridge before you set a date, because it can be one of the largest line items in the early years of retirement. Marketplace premium credits depend on income, so the same withdrawal decisions that drive taxes can also change what coverage costs.

Medicare does not end health spending. Premiums, deductibles, dental, vision and hearing costs remain. The Employee Benefit Research Institute's 2025 projections put the savings a 65-year-old couple with median prescription costs would need for a 90% chance of covering health expenses at $405,000 with a Medigap Plan G policy and $203,000 with Medicare Advantage. Long-term care is a separate exposure that Medicare largely does not cover; see Medicaid and long-term care planning for how a care event fits into the income plan.

— Question five —

How much of your monthly income does debt still take?

Retirement income is mostly fixed. Debt payments are too.

  1. List every balance, rate and payment

    Include credit cards, auto loans, personal loans, a home equity line and the mortgage. A complete list is the only way to see what fixed income has to cover.

  2. Pay the highest rate first while you still earn

    Paying a balance from salary is generally cheaper than paying it from withdrawals that count as taxable income.

  3. Subtract the remaining payments from the income schedule

    What is left is the amount available for living costs. If it falls short of essential spending, the date or the spending plan needs to move.

  4. Check the tax cost of paying debt from an IRA

    A withdrawal from a traditional account to clear a balance counts as income and can raise the tax on Social Security or trigger a Medicare surcharge.

Carrying high-interest debt into retirement can also create pressure to claim Social Security early just to meet payments, which turns a temporary problem into a permanent reduction.

— Exeter —

Testing a date from Exeter.

Exeter households often reach these questions with a mix of income sources that do not line up neatly. Exeter Hospital and Phillips Exeter Academy are major local employers, and many residents commute to the Seacoast, Portsmouth or across the line to Massachusetts, so a single couple can bring a 403(b), a 401(k) left at a former employer and two Social Security records with different claiming ages. For Exeter residents looking for financial advice from a financial advisor, retirement planning and retirement income planning, the five questions above are where those accounts have to be fitted into one schedule before a date is set. KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions serves Exeter from Londonderry, about 35 minutes away, and by video.

— Where KBR sits —

One person, one schedule, all five questions.

An independent, fee-only registered investment adviser in Londonderry, New Hampshire.

KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC is registered in New Hampshire and Massachusetts and is paid only by its clients. Bernie Ross, in financial services since 1997, is the only person who advises clients. The work starts by gathering tax returns, Social Security statements, pension and account statements and estate documents before anything is recommended, then builds a retirement income plan that answers the five questions with your figures: an income schedule, a tax path, the claiming decision and stress scenarios. Rollover questions are handled in the same model through 401(k) and IRA rollover analysis. The process is described on Our Approach.

— Common questions —

Common questions.

How do I know if I am ready to set a retirement date?

You are ready when you can show, year by year, which income source covers your essential bills, which account each withdrawal comes from and what it costs in tax, how health coverage is paid for until Medicare at 65, what a market decline in the first five years would do, and how much of your income debt still takes. If any of those has no answer, the date is premature.

Should I claim Social Security at 62, 67 or 70?

There is no single right age. For anyone born in 1960 or later, claiming at 62 pays 70% of the full benefit for life, claiming at 67 pays the full benefit, and claiming at 70 pays 124%. Health, other savings, taxes and a spouse's survivor benefit all affect which age fits a particular household.

How much will health care cost in retirement?

EBRI's 2025 projections put the savings a 65-year-old couple with median prescription costs would need for a 90% chance of covering health expenses at $405,000 with Medigap Plan G and $203,000 with Medicare Advantage. If you retire before 65, coverage until Medicare also has to be priced, and long-term care is a separate cost Medicare largely does not cover.

What is a sustainable withdrawal rate in retirement?

Morningstar's research for 2026 put the highest starting withdrawal rate with a 90% probability of lasting 30 years at 3.9% of the initial portfolio, adjusted for inflation each year. Flexible spending can support a higher start. The figure is a research benchmark; a household's own rate depends on its other income, taxes and time horizon.

When does a Roth conversion make sense before retirement?

Conversions are often considered in the lower-income years after paychecks stop and before Social Security and required minimum distributions begin. Converting too much in one year can raise the tax on Social Security and trigger Medicare premium surcharges two years later, so conversions are usually modeled across several years. This is not tax advice; confirm with your CPA.

— Related —

What this connects to.

Bernie Ross, founder of KBR Financial Solutions

About the author

Bernie Ross is the founder of KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC, an independent, fee-only registered investment adviser in Londonderry, New Hampshire. He has worked in financial services since 1997 and personally handles the planning and services every client relationship. Read more about Bernie.

This article is general information and is not personalized investment, tax or legal advice. It does not consider your individual circumstances. Figures cited are from the sources named and may change; past research results do not predict future outcomes. Consult your CPA or attorney on tax and legal matters. Advisory services are offered through KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. See Disclosures.

Test your retirement date before you set it.

Bring your last tax return and your Social Security statement. The first conversation costs nothing and commits you to nothing.