An open brass compass, reading glasses and a notebook resting on a nautical chart on a wooden table by a window
— Insights —

How an Advisor's Pay Can Shape Social Security Claiming Advice

When you claim Social Security is one of the few retirement decisions that pays out for life. Research suggests the way an advisor is paid can be associated with the timing they recommend.

By Bernie Ross8 min read

Can the way an advisor is paid affect their Social Security claiming advice?

It can. Research by David Blanchett and Jason Fichtner published in 2024 found that households working with a financial advisor tended to claim Social Security earlier than those without one, and that the pattern was associated with commission-based compensation. Claiming earlier leaves more savings invested, which can benefit an advisor paid on assets or product sales. Ask how the advisor is paid, and test any recommendation against your longevity, survivor benefit and tax picture.

— Why pay matters here —

Claiming early keeps money in the account.

That fact alone can create a quiet conflict of interest.

Delaying Social Security usually means drawing more from savings in the meantime. A household that retires at 64 and waits until 70 to claim pays six years of living costs from its portfolio. A household that claims at 62 leaves those assets invested. For an advisor paid a percentage of assets under management, or paid when products are bought, the second path keeps more money in the accounts that generate compensation.

That does not mean every early-claim recommendation is conflicted. Claiming early can be the right answer for a household with shorter life expectancy, no savings to bridge the gap, or a spouse whose benefit would not depend on it. The point is narrower: a claiming recommendation is one of the places where an advisor's interests and a client's can diverge, so it deserves the same scrutiny as a product recommendation. For the broader role an adviser plays in this decision, see a fiduciary advisor's role in Social Security claiming.

— What the research found —

Advised households tended to claim earlier.

The finding is descriptive. It shows an association, not proof of cause.

David Blanchett and Jason Fichtner, writing in 2024 and drawing on the Federal Reserve's Survey of Consumer Finances, found that households working with a financial professional claimed Social Security earlier on average than comparable households without one. The pattern was associated with how the professional was paid, with commission-based compensation linked to earlier claiming. The authors were careful to note that the data cannot show that the advice caused the timing.

The cost of claiming early compounds with longevity. For anyone born in 1960 or later, claiming at 62 pays 70% of the full retirement age benefit for life, and waiting until 70 pays 124%, about 77% more per month than the age-62 amount. Benefits are also adjusted for inflation each year, so the gap between an early and a delayed claim grows in dollars over time. For a married couple, the higher earner's claiming age also sets the survivor benefit, which can last decades after the first death.

— Three tests —

How to test any claiming recommendation.

A sound recommendation shows its assumptions. These three tests expose weak ones.

  1. Are the longevity assumptions realistic?

    Ask what age the analysis assumes each spouse lives to, and why. An analysis built on average life expectancy can understate the value of delaying for a healthy couple, because the odds that at least one spouse reaches 90 are meaningfully higher than the odds for either one alone.

  2. Does the comparison invest early benefits aggressively?

    A common argument for claiming early is that the checks can be invested. Ask what return the model assumes on those dollars. A delayed benefit is an inflation-adjusted lifetime income stream; comparing it against an optimistic stock return tilts the answer toward claiming early.

  3. Is the survivor benefit in the model?

    The surviving spouse keeps the larger of the two benefits. A recommendation that looks only at the higher earner's own break-even age ignores what the other spouse will live on after the first death.

A recommendation that fails any one of the three deserves a second opinion before anything is filed. Filing is hard to undo: after the first year, the only way to raise a reduced benefit is to suspend it at full retirement age and earn delayed credits from that point.

— Compensation and claiming —

Each pay model, and the question it raises.

Every compensation model has a potential conflict. The question is whether it touches your claiming date.

How common advisor compensation models can interact with Social Security claiming advice
How the advisor is paidPossible pull on claiming adviceQuestion to ask
Fixed or hourly planning feeNone tied to the claiming dateWhat exactly does the fee cover, and is the claiming analysis included?
Percentage of assets managedDelaying draws down managed assets, which reduces the feeHow do you handle the fact that delaying would lower what I pay you?
Commissions on productsAssets left invested can be directed into commissionable productsWhat do you earn if I claim at 70 instead of 62?
Fee-based (fees plus commissions)Both of the above, depending on the accountWhich of my accounts or products would pay you a commission?

Fee-only means the adviser is paid only by clients, with no commissions, trailing commissions, revenue sharing or product-sponsor payments. It removes the product-sale pull, but an asset-based fee still carries the drawdown conflict in the second row. A fiduciary names that conflict without being asked twice. Compensation is disclosed in Item 5 of Form ADV Part 2A; for how the models differ more broadly, see fee-only vs. commission-based retirement advisors.

— Situations that need more —

Three households where a simple age comparison falls short.

  1. Married couples coordinating two claims

    Each spouse's claim affects the other's lifetime income. The analysis should show which spouse claims first, any spousal benefit on the other's record, and what the survivor receives if the higher earner dies first.

  2. Public-sector retirees after the Social Security Fairness Act

    The Act, signed January 5, 2025, repealed the Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset. Teachers, police, firefighters and others with pensions from work not covered by Social Security may have planned around reductions that no longer apply, so earlier claiming analyses are worth rerunning.

  3. Pre-retirees who need bridge income

    Delaying requires paying living costs from savings or work until the benefit starts. Those withdrawals change taxable income in the bridge years, which affects the tax on other income, Roth conversion room and future Medicare premiums.

— Trust fund worries —

Should the trust fund forecast change your claiming date?

Fear of a cut is a common reason to claim early. The numbers argue for caution.

The 2026 Social Security Trustees Report, released June 9, 2026, projects that the retirement trust fund can pay scheduled benefits in full until the fourth quarter of 2032, after which continuing income would cover about 78% of scheduled benefits if Congress does not act. The combined retirement and disability funds are projected to last until 2034, with about 83% payable.

Claiming early does not protect against a future reduction. Any across-the-board cut would apply to the benefit you are receiving, and an early claim locks in a permanent 30% reduction on top of whatever Congress decides. A delayed benefit starts from a higher base. The forecast is a reason to plan for a range of outcomes, not a reason to accept a smaller check for life.

— Litchfield —

Claiming decisions in Litchfield.

Litchfield sits on the east bank of the Merrimack River between Hudson and Merrimack, and many households there have careers that ran through Manchester, Nashua or across the state line into Massachusetts. That mix often means one spouse with a long private-sector record and another with a public pension or a shorter work history, which is exactly where spousal, survivor and Fairness Act questions overlap. For Litchfield residents looking for financial advice from a financial advisor, retirement planning and retirement income planning, the claiming decision is worth modeling for both spouses before either one files. KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions serves Litchfield from Londonderry, about 20 minutes away, and by video.

— Where KBR sits —

How KBR approaches the claiming decision.

An independent, fee-only registered investment adviser in Londonderry, New Hampshire.

KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC is paid only by its clients and receives no commissions, so no product sale depends on when you claim. Bernie Ross, in financial services since 1997, is the only person who advises clients. Social Security planning at KBR models each spouse at 62, full retirement age and 70 inside the household's retirement income plan, with taxes, Medicare premiums and the survivor benefit included. The firm's fee schedule and the conflicts it discloses are in Form ADV Part 2A, linked from Disclosures, and its record is on the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site under CRD 126079. Before hiring anyone, you can verify a fee-only fiduciary planner yourself.

— Common questions —

Common questions.

Do financial advisors tell clients to claim Social Security too early?

Some research suggests advised households claim earlier on average. A 2024 analysis by David Blanchett and Jason Fichtner of the Survey of Consumer Finances found earlier claiming among households working with a financial professional, associated with commission-based compensation. The study shows a pattern, not that any individual recommendation was wrong.

How can I tell whether claiming advice is objective?

Ask how the advisor is paid and whether delaying would reduce their compensation. Then check the recommendation's assumptions: realistic longevity for both spouses, a conservative return on any benefits invested early, and the survivor benefit included. A recommendation that fails one of those tests deserves a second opinion.

How much more is Social Security at 70 than at 62?

For anyone born in 1960 or later, claiming at 62 pays 70% of the full retirement age benefit and claiming at 70 pays 124%, so the age-70 benefit is about 77% larger per month. Both amounts receive annual cost-of-living adjustments.

Should I claim early because Social Security might run out of money?

The 2026 Trustees Report projects the retirement trust fund can pay full scheduled benefits until the fourth quarter of 2032, then about 78% if Congress does not act. Any cut would apply to the benefit you are receiving, so an early claim adds a permanent reduction on top of it rather than avoiding one.

What changed for public pensioners under the Social Security Fairness Act?

The Act, signed January 5, 2025, repealed the Windfall Elimination Provision and the Government Pension Offset. People with pensions from work not covered by Social Security, such as some teachers and public safety employees, may now receive larger benefits than earlier projections assumed, so claiming analyses done before 2025 are worth rerunning.

— Related —

What this connects to.

Bernie Ross, founder of KBR Financial Solutions

About the author

Bernie Ross is the founder of KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC, an independent, fee-only registered investment adviser in Londonderry, New Hampshire. He has worked in financial services since 1997 and personally handles the planning and services every client relationship. Read more about Bernie.

This article is general information and is not personalized investment, tax or legal advice. It does not consider your individual circumstances. Research findings describe patterns across households and do not predict the result for any individual. Consult your CPA or attorney on tax and legal matters. Advisory services are offered through KBR Retirement & Investment Solutions, LLC, a registered investment adviser. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. See Disclosures.

Test your claiming date before you file.

Bring your Social Security statement and last tax return. The first conversation costs nothing and commits you to nothing.